External Article Review no_lock Open Access

External Article Review of: Association Between Aluminum Exposure from Vaccines Before Age 24 Months and Persistent Asthma at Age 24 to 59 Months

  • Martin Kulldorff

Submitted: Jan 30, 2025| Published: Jan 30, 2025 | DOI: https://doi.org/10.70542/rcj-japh-art-f1wnwa

100

1.4k

 

 

 

Citations

Views

Downloads

Comments

Views

100

1.4k

 

 

 

Citations

Views

Downloads

Comments

Views

search_icon
search_icon Abstract
search_icon Introduction
search_icon Study Strengths
search_icon Interpretation
search_icon Need for Further Analyses
search_icon Summary
search_icon References
Reader Comments search_icon Tools search_icon
search_icon
search_icon Abstract
search_icon Introduction
search_icon Study Strengths
search_icon Interpretation
search_icon Need for Further Analyses
search_icon Summary
search_icon References
Rejoinder
Authors
Article
Supplemental Materials

Reader Comments

add_comment

Comment

We welcome and encourage comments from both scientists and the general public. Comments are moderated solely for appropriateness and will be posted after review.

June 12, 2025 1:11 PM

Steve Robison

Natural experiment basis for assessing aluminum risk

Another potential basis for assessing aluminum effects on child asthma is to consider drinking water. Exposure to aluminum through air pollution may be subject to substantial variability across a community- however drinking water exposure is likely less variant per community. Aluminum content of drinking water varies substantially across communities based on either processing or on natural geographic structures- finding high and low exposure communities within the same regions should be feasible.

Another issue is the bioavailability of environmental aluminum. The literature generally assumes that bioavailability of aluminum in water is higher than in food. For comparability to vaccine aluminum exposure, need to start by assessing time to achieve a vaccine level of exposure through water (or air or food), based on bioavailability. Absorption of dietary aluminum is largely through the upper intestine, and any potential variability in this absorption capacity by population would need to factored in.

display more display less

February 6, 2025 10:28 AM

Ed Gomes

Typo

There seems to be a typo in the 3rd paragraph of the "Interpretation" section. Interesting study. Thanks for making this available to the public.

display more display less

February 5, 2025 6:42 PM

Vinu Arumugham

Vaccines contaminated with aeroallergen, plant, food, animal, fungal, bacterial, viral proteins cause the development of asthma and allergies. Aluminum adjuvant makes it worse.

Martin,

We have known for a 100+ years now that injecting proteins into humans causes the development of deadly allergies to those proteins. Subsequent exposure to those protein aerosols can result in fatal asthma.

https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/medicine/1913/richet/lecture/

This is taught in medical schools today.

UC Irvine, School of Medicine, Immunology notes:
https://pdfcoffee.com/notes-of-immunology-pdf-free.html
pg. 157

Vaccines contain or are contaminated with thousands of proteins. Animal/plant/food/fungal/aeroallergen/bacterial/viral proteins contaminate all vaccines.

Aluminum adjuvant boosts the allergic immune response to all these proteins. Thus creating allergies to even the tiniest levels of residual proteins in the vaccines.

https://www.jacionline.org/article/S0091-6749(15)02364-7/fulltext

So it is inexplicable that you are still "studying" asking for "additional investigations", "hypothesizing" while millions of people are being assaulted using these vaccines, everyday.

Injecting vaccines is barbaric, to put it mildly. "Public health" needs to stop this assault immediately.

display more display less